Skip to Content
Closeouts - Hard to Find Cigars
Finding the right cigar for you is always an exciting adventure. But finding those rare gems? That could be a tad bit exhausting and frustrating. These “unicorns” of the cigar industry may be so hard to find because they’re collected privately and remain in the small circles of the cigar industry.
List By:

Fratello Vice Versa Churchill

Fratello Vice Versa Churchill
SKU: FRATV7052
Package: Box of 12
Size: 7 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Churchill

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Experience the freedom of choice with the Fratello Vice Versa cigar. Crafted by brand owner Omar Frias, this unique cigar features both a light-colored and dark-colored cap on each end. Simply cut both ends and light according to your desired flavor profile. The band is color-coded for easy selection - yellow for mild and red for full-bodied. So go ahead and make your choice, then sit back and enjoy either a bold and spicy or smooth and mild smoke - it's all up to you.

$148.18
Retail Price: $204.54
Save: $56.36
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Fratello Vice Versa Churchill 5 pack

$71.05

Gregorio Flavor Savor Corona

Gregorio Flavor Savor Corona
SKU: GREGFS5542
Package: Bundles of 25
Size: 5.5 x 42
Strength: Mild
Shape: Corona

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Featuring a mild and sweet flavor, this petite cigar will appeal to both men and women alike. Enjoy this as an early morning or afternoon smoke, or..... save it for an after-dinner treat. Vanilla, creme brûlée, and carmel flavors make this a sweet tip.

$99.26
Retail Price: $134.66
Save: $35.40
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Gregorio Flavor Savor Corona 5 pack

$25.87

Gregorio Flavor Savor Short Panatela

Gregorio Flavor Savor Short Panatela
SKU: GREGFS5730
Package: Bundles of 25
Size: 5.75 x 30
Strength: Mild
Shape: Short Panatela

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Enjoy the mild and sweet flavor of the Flavor Savor....This petite cigar is an indulgence for both gentlemen and ladies. You can enjoy it in the morning or afternoon, or... you can save it for after dinner. A sweet tip with vanilla, creme brûlée, and carmel flavors.

$76.60
Retail Price: $102.28
Save: $25.68
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Gregorio Flavor Savor Short Panatela 5 pack

$20.85

Headley Grange No. 6

Headley Grange No. 6
SKU: 1213205
Package: Box of 10
Size: 6.5 x 56
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro
In addition to being bold, bold, and gutsy, Headley Grange cigars have been described as big, bold, and gutsy. A blend of Nicaraguan long fillers and binders expertly rolled in Ecuadorian-grown Sumatra wrappers, Headley Grange cigars are available in five shapes at Tabacalera La Alianza in Santiago, DR. Among other accolades, Headley Grange made the Top Cigars of 2012 and Top 25 Cigars of The Year lists. Try these impressive cigars brim with complexity and a captivating aroma.
$96.35
Retail Price: $130.50
Save: $34.15
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

J Fuego Gran Reserva Original new

J Fuego Gran Reserva Original
SKU: 1214663
Package: Packs of 60
Size: 5 x 44
Strength: Medium
Shape: Corona

Experience the J. Fuego ORIGEN cigar - a rich, limited quantity smoke crafted by Tobaccos S.A. and J. Fuego himself. This bold, spicy cigar features a Brazilian Corojo wrapper and a blend of Corojo filler tobacco from Honduras and Nicaragua. Its smooth draw and long, leathery finish are consistent throughout, reflecting the excellence of J. Fuego's popular Origen line. Now, fans of this line can also enjoy the new Origen Maduro - exploding with flavors of chocolate, leather, and espresso. The decadent band and sleek Brazilian wrapper only add to its allure. Select from Robusto, Toro Grande, Corona, or Belicoso - you won't want to miss out on this long-awaited addition to the Origen family. Don't hesitate any longer - order now and treat yourself to an unforgettable smoking experience!

$167.96
Retail Price: $232.80
Save: $64.84
Availability: In Stock

J. London "The Ripper" Robusto

J. London "The Ripper" Robusto
SKU: JLR5250
Package: Box of 10
Size: 5.25 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

The J. London brand stands in a tier shared by only a select few cigar brands. For those who may be unaware, this is the top-shelf tier where ultra-premium blends reside and are reserved for special occasions. These are not your average yardwork cigars. Instead, they are reserved for moments that call for something exceptional. For The Ripper blend from J. London, a combination of Dominican and Nicaraguan tobaccos is used, wrapped in an Ecuadorian Habano binder and finished off with a smooth Ecuadorian Corojo wrapper. This medium to full-bodied blend offers flavors of cedar, earth, and pepper on the finish. Each box contains one cigar with a unique dagger design carved from tobacco on the wrapper.

$108.40
Retail Price: $147.72
Save: $39.32
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

J. London "The Ripper" Robusto 5 pack

$62.24

Kickoff Blue Toro Box Pressed

Kickoff Blue Toro Box Pressed
SKU: KOB6054
Package: Bundles of 25
Size: 6 x 54
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

As football season kicks off, we invite you to elevate your game day experience with Privada Cigar Club. Our Kickoff Red and Kickoff Blue cigars for the 2024/2025 season will make this football season one to remember. No matter the outcome of your team's game, you'll feel like a champion with one of our expertly crafted cigars in hand. Representing NFC teams is the smooth and bold Kickoff Blue Natural, while AFC teams are represented by the warm and flavorful Kickoff Red Habano. These 6x54 box-pressed cigars are the result of Jochy Blanco's skills as a third-generation Dominican tobacco farmer and master blender at Tabacalera Palma. With these Dominican puros, expect a perfect balance of flavors that will leave your taste buds satisfied. Trust us, Dominican cigars have never tasted better.

$243.63
Retail Price: $340.90
Save: $97.27
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Kickoff Blue Toro Box Pressed 5 pack

$57.84

Kristoff Veinte 20th Anniversary Toro

Kristoff Veinte 20th Anniversary Toro
SKU: KRISVE6254
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6.25 x 54
Strength: Full
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Kristoff cigars were introduced by Glen Case in 2004 to great acclaim among both traditional and contemporary cigar enthusiasts. Over the past two decades, Kristoff has become renowned for crafting top-quality cigars with exceptional flavor profiles. To commemorate their anniversary, they introduced the Kristoff Veinte 20th Anniversary cigar - a full-strength, full-bodied blend of four nations and a dark maduro wrapper that exudes rich notes of chocolate. From start to finish, the Veinte will delight any palate with its exquisite complexity.

$227.73
Retail Price: $318.18
Save: $90.45
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Kristoff Veinte 20th Anniversary Toro 5 pack

$66.65

La Imperioso Magicos

La Imperioso Magicos
SKU: 1213671
Package: Box of 24
Size: 4.5 x 52
Strength: Full
Shape: Rothschild
A must-smoke from Crowned Heads, La Imperiosa - translated as the Imperative - is another must-smoke. As a regular production Rothschild, you can enjoy the Nicaraguan flavor of the ultra-limited Las Calaveras 2014. Buy 'em and smoke 'em, we'll make more!
$214.36
Retail Price: $299.08
Save: $84.72
Availability: In Stock

Las Calaveras Edicion Limitada 2023 LC54

Las Calaveras Edicion Limitada 2023 LC54
SKU: LCAL5554
Package: Box of 24
Size: 5.625 x 54
Strength: Full
Shape: Torpedo

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

With a savory complexity complemented by spices, coffee, and sweetness, this cigar is a potent, flavorful cigar. My Father Cigars handmade the cigars in Nicaragua with a Connecticut Broadleaf maduro wrapper that surrounds a Nicaraguan binder and filler. As its name implies, Las Calaveras Edicion Limitada 2023 is produced in limited quantities, so order your boxes today to enjoy this year's rich flavors and fine craftsmanship.

$290.60
Retail Price: $408.00
Save: $117.40
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Las Calaveras Edicion Limitada 2023 LC54 5 pack

$70.88

Leon Jimines No. 1

Leon Jimines No. 1
SKU: 02LE1
Package: Box of 25
Size: 7.5 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Churchill
Leon Jimenes Connecticut No 1 is a box of 10 classic parejo cigars made by La Aurora Cigar Factory, based in the Dominican Republic and renowned for their high-end smokes. Their Connecticut No 1 blend is crafted with light wrappers cultivated in Ecuador, along with a well-aged mixture of Dominican and Nicaraguan long-leaf tobaccos. This mild smoke is ideal for those who prefer smooth and refined tastes; the meticulous rolling process results in a consistently flavorful, medium-bodied experience.
$152.29
Retail Price: $210.42
Save: $58.13
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Leon Jimines No. 1 5 pack

$37.62

Leon Jimines Robusto

Leon Jimines Robusto
SKU: 02LER
Package: Box of 25
Size: 5 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto
A handmade cigar, the Leon Jimenes Robusto cigar features long filler from the Dominican Republic, a binder from the Dominican Republic, and an insert from the Dominican Republic. With a mild strength and aroma of cinnamon and cedar wood, this cigar is perfect for every evening.
$134.98
Retail Price: $185.68
Save: $50.70
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Leon Jimines Robusto 5 pack

$33.78

Limited Cigar Association: Incredible Hug East Edition by AJ Fernandez

Limited Cigar Association: Incredible Hug East Edition by AJ Fernandez
SKU: IHE6056
Package: Bundles of 25
Size: 6 x 56
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Privada Cigar Club launched the Limited Cigar Association in 2020, granting connoisseurs an unprecedented opportunity: Partnering with renowned cigar brands and personalities, Privada produces limited-release cigars exclusively available through LCA and its retail partners. With a new release every month, you can always expect something intriguing from the LCA. Its June 2023 release — the Incredible Hug cigar— is an especially novel offering by AJ Fernandez that offers a powerful punch tempered by a gentle caress on the palate. This two-edition cigar is split between EAST and WEST versions based on retailers' location, and here we have access to the EAST edition made of Nicaraguan Habano wrapper in 6" x 56 size.

$242.85
Retail Price: $339.78
Save: $96.93
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Limited Cigar Association: Incredible Hug East Edition by AJ Fernandez 5 pack

$57.67

Los Statos Deluxe Gigante new

Los Statos Deluxe Gigante
SKU: 1215744
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6 x 60
Strength: Medium
Shape: Gordo

Since joining forces, Matt Booth and Justin Andrews have taken the blends produced at the HATSA factory in Honduras to a whole new level. With fresh art and new blends, the Los Statos Deluxe is a testament to their talents. Alongside the Honduran blending team, they have created a cigar that demands respect. Featuring Nicaraguan and Dominican long-fillers, expertly blended with a Nicaraguan binder, this cigar evolves as you smoke it. Topped off with an Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper, this medium-bodied cigar offers flavors of coffee, chocolate, and subtle black pepper. Don't miss out on adding this enticing blend to your humidor today!

$161.80
Retail Price: $224.00
Save: $62.20
Availability: In Stock

Luciano The Dreamer Hermoso No. 4

Luciano The Dreamer Hermoso No. 4
SKU: 1213758
Package: Box of 15
Size: 5 x 48
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

Experience a balanced, medium-bodied cigar that unlocks the imagination with its complex flavors, complemented by delectable chocolate and subtle spice undertones. A reddish Ecuadorian Habano wrapper conceals an Ecuadorian Sumatra binder and a blend of Nicaraguan and Peruvian fillers. Crafted by Luciano Meirelles, CEO and co-founder of Luciano Cigars, The Dreamer was created to inspire aficionados to dream big and bring those dreams to life. Handmade with expertise in Nicaragua by Luciano Cigars, the Luciano The Dream Hermoso No. 4 received an impressive 88 rating from Cigar Insider.

$154.10
Retail Price: $213.00
Save: $58.90
Availability: In Stock

Makers Mark 538

Makers Mark 538
SKU: MAKMRK5038
Package: Box of 25
Size: 5 x 38
Strength: Mild
Shape: Petite Corona

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

It used to be commonplace for cigar aficionados to douse their sticks with brandy or bourbon before kindling them up, but such practices have since ceased and rightly so; the results could only be described as 'quite a mess.' Maker's Mark now can provide enthusiasts with the combination of fine cigars and bourbon through an innovative infusion process. Refraining from directly exposing the tobacco to the liquid, Maker's Mark instead infuse their cigars with select flavours and scents unique to their recipe. Crafted using Dominican long-filler tobaccos, these cigars deliver a smooth yet distinctive smoke enhanced by the refinement of Maker's Mark bourbon. Lastly, each stogie is encased in a glass tube sealed with the famous red wax bearing Maker's Mark's signature, making sure the fine aromas of both bourbon and tobacco remain perfectly preserved at optimal humidity.

$198.30
Retail Price: $276.14
Save: $77.84
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Makers Mark 538 5 pack

$47.80

Maria Mancini Magic Mountain

Maria Mancini Magic Mountain
SKU: 02MMMM20
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6 x 54
Strength: Medium
Shape: Pyramid
Maria Mancini's Magic Mountain Figurado is one of the most coveted sizes in the line. The H2000 wrapper covers a Honduran binder, aged Nicaraguan filler, and a Honduran binder. One of the best bargains in the whole, wide cigar world, this bursting Cuban style cigar is packed with rich, earthy flavor.
$91.62
Retail Price: $123.74
Save: $32.12
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Maria Mancini Magic Mountain 5 pack

$28.97

Montecristo B.R.M. and Humidor

Montecristo B.R.M. and Humidor
SKU: MCBRM6052
Package: Box of 40
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Montecristo has joined forces with esteemed watchmaker B.R.M Chronographes to introduce a highly exclusive cabinet, described as “a first of its kind.” This humidor contains 40 cigars made by the Plasencia family in Nicaragua and a custom-made Montecristo B.R.M watch, fitted with an automatic winder. The cigars are sized at 6" x 52, featuring tobacco from the Plasencia family's farms throughout Nicaragua's four primary growing regions: Jalapa, Condega, Estelí, and Ometepe—the blend is medium-bodied. The watch features a 44mm stainless steel case boasting a skeleton dial, sapphire crystal glass on the front and back, Montecristo’s Fleur-de-lis at the “8” position on the dial, and more.

 

$8,755.00
Retail Price: $12,500.00
Save: $3,745.00
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Murcielago Toro

Murcielago Toro
SKU: MUR6052
Package: Bundles of 20
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

There are mouthwatering notes of cocoa and sweet spices in this medium-strength cigar. With its dark Mexican San Andres Maduro wrapper covering a Nicaraguan binder and filler, the Murcielago is a cigar for cigar aficionados who love maduro cigars or who wish to venture into the darker side of cigars.

$175.23
Retail Price: $243.18
Save: $67.95
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Murcielago Toro 5 pack

$52.12

Noble Cigars Collection Act One Broadleaf Claro Toro

Noble Cigars Collection Act One Broadleaf Claro Toro
SKU: NA16052
Package: Box of 10
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Full
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

This is a full-bodied “Doble Ligero,” a premium handmade Dominican cigar. Act One combines balance and complexity in a beautifully Toro format. Aged Dominican filler tobaccos add extraordinary complexity. As the intensity increases, fresh spice, dark chocolate, fruit, honey, and cedar challenge the palate.

$124.32
Retail Price: $170.46
Save: $46.14
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Noble Cigars Collection Act One Broadleaf Claro Toro 5 pack

$71.05

Noble Cigars Collection Act Two Toro

Noble Cigars Collection Act Two Toro
SKU: NA26052
Package: Box of 10
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Full
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

This is a full-bodied “Doble Ligero” a premium handmade Dominican cigar. This cigar has a harmonious combination of balanced flavors in a beautifully Toro format. Dominican filler and binder tobaccos have aged to provide stunning complexity. This cigar offers a balance between oaky, earthy aromas and hearty notes of pepper, chocolate, and coffee, making it a must-have cigar for your humidor.

$124.32
Retail Price: $170.46
Save: $46.14
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Noble Cigars Collection Act Two Toro 5 pack

$71.05

Oscar Valladares McFly Toro new

Oscar Valladares McFly Toro
SKU: 1211003
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

Oscar Valladares is once again paying tribute to the 80s with his latest release. If you're feeling nostalgic, look no further than this manufacturer who has produced some of the most retro packaging on the market. In this sequel to the Super Fly, Valladares draws inspiration from one of the decade's most iconic films. While Marty McFly needed a DeLorean and 1.21 gigawatts to save his existence, these cigars require neither. The combo of Dominican, Honduran, and Nicaraguan fillers inside a Honduran binder are perfectly complemented by the visually stunning Mexican wrapper. Adorned with double bands and a vaporwave-inspired design, this cigar captures all the essence of the 80s. Medium-full in body, it's sure to add some brightness to your humidor. Don't wait too long to get your hands on the Oscar Valladares McFly – time is ticking!

$206.46
Retail Price: $287.80
Save: $81.34
Availability: In Stock

Pichardo Clasico Natural Toro

Pichardo Clasico Natural Toro
SKU: PCN6550
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6.5 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

The Pichardo Clasico Natural Toro is a well-balanced smoke with a savory profile. Its savory, reddish Ecuadorian Sun-grown wrapper is expertly placed over a binder and filler made of premium Nicaraguan leaves. It is handmade in Nicaragua at the Tabacalera Pichardo factory and offers a smooth, flavorful medium-bodied smoking experience with notes of earth and spice accompanied by a rich tobacco flavor.

$163.45
Retail Price: $226.36
Save: $62.91
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Pichardo Clasico Natural Toro 5 pack

$48.86

Romeo y Julieta Book of Love Toro

Romeo y Julieta Book of Love Toro
SKU: RJBL6052
Package: Box of 10
Size: 6 x 52
Shape: Toro

No cigar lover can deny Romeo Y Julieta's influence on the global industry. Founded in Cuba, they are one of the most widely known brands in the world. Today, their newest entry into the market is an impressive limited-edition blend: Romeo’s Book of Love. Comprised of a Dominican core and binder, as well as an Ecuadorian wrapper, this richly flavored cigar offers up notes of cedar, dark chocolate and a slight spiciness on the finish. This medium to full-bodied smoke comes in an exquisite 10-count box that looks like an old book. Whether you love or hate them, it's clear this outstanding limited edition is another example of why Romeo Y Julieta remains at the top of its game.

$108.10
Retail Price: $147.28
Save: $39.18
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
5 Pack

Romeo y Julieta Book of Love Toro 5 pack

$62.07

Sabor Cubiche Cafe Con Leche

Sabor Cubiche Cafe Con Leche
SKU: SABCUB
Package: Bundles of 20
Size: 4 x 40
Strength: Mild
Shape: Corona
THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO HAWAII OR UTAH

Jorge Leon, a very close friend of ours, handcrafted the Sabor Cubiche Café con Leche in Nicaragua. It's a famous Spanish coffee that's steamed with milk for a smooth, rich taste and aroma. This one-of-a-kind cigar has that wonderful, rich aroma from the moment you unwrap it. Featuring a mellow smoke and an oily Connecticut wrapper and the finest quality blend of aged long filler tobaccos. This cigar is not only incredibly satisfying, but highly aromatic with its infusion of dark roast coffee.

$27.75
Retail Price: $32.50
Save: $4.75
Availability: In Stock
Showing 26 to 50 of 60

Disclaimer

TheCigarStore.com does not sell tobacco products to anyone under the age of 21. TheCigarStore.com does not sell cigarettes. It is unlawful to purchase cigars below the minimum age. If you are not at least 21 years of age, please do not enter our site.