Skip to Content
Closeouts - Hard to Find Cigars
Finding the right cigar for you is always an exciting adventure. But finding those rare gems? That could be a tad bit exhausting and frustrating. These “unicorns” of the cigar industry may be so hard to find because they’re collected privately and remain in the small circles of the cigar industry.

Fiat Lux Acumen 5 pack

Fiat Lux Acumen
SKU: 12135485pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 56
Strength: Full
Shape: Toro Grande
Luciano Meirelles and ACE Prime Cigars have crafted the Fiat Lux in Nicaragua at Tabacalera Pichardo, well-known for producing Crowned Heads cigars. The Latin phrase appears in the Bible and translates to 'Let there be light,' but Luciano suggests that it symbolizes 'enlightenment' when one experiences the complexity of flavours and introspection during a smoke. Although serious, Fiat Lux offers an enjoyable experience. The dark, high-priming ACE Prime wrapper ensures a rewarding draw throughout.
$53.77
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

El Reloj El Ocho 5 pack

El Reloj El Ocho
SKU: 02EROCHO5pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 8 x 53
Strength: Medium
Shape: Presidente
El Reloj (in Spanish "the clock") is a one-of-a-kind cigar, made in the last operating cigar factory in Tampa, Florida, once the fine cigar capital of the world. Its flavorful smoke can be smoked for a very reasonable price. This 8" by 53 ring stick features aged tobaccos from the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua and Honduras, which are wrapped in Ecuadorian Havana Seed Sungrown leaves.
$23.09
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Leon Jimines No. 1 5 pack

Leon Jimines No. 1
SKU: 02LE15pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 7.5 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Churchill
Leon Jimenes Connecticut No 1 is a box of 10 classic parejo cigars made by La Aurora Cigar Factory, based in the Dominican Republic and renowned for their high-end smokes. Their Connecticut No 1 blend is crafted with light wrappers cultivated in Ecuador, along with a well-aged mixture of Dominican and Nicaraguan long-leaf tobaccos. This mild smoke is ideal for those who prefer smooth and refined tastes; the meticulous rolling process results in a consistently flavorful, medium-bodied experience.
$37.62
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Leon Jimines Robusto 5 pack

Leon Jimines Robusto
SKU: 02LER5pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 5 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto
A handmade cigar, the Leon Jimenes Robusto cigar features long filler from the Dominican Republic, a binder from the Dominican Republic, and an insert from the Dominican Republic. With a mild strength and aroma of cinnamon and cedar wood, this cigar is perfect for every evening.
$33.78
Availability: In Stock

Xen by Nish Patel Short Robusto 5 pack

Xen by Nish Patel Short Robusto
SKU: 02XESRO5pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 4 x 54
Strength: Mild
Shape: Short Robusto
A medium bodied cigar with great balance, XEN by Nish Patel Short Robusto features flavors of sweet spice, coffee, cedar, with a nutty finish. As a box pressed cigar with an Ecuador Connecticut wrapper, XEN by Nish Patel is made by Rocky Patel and reflects what he loves most about cigars.
$26.77
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Xen by Nish Patel Toro 5 pack

Xen by Nish Patel Toro
SKU: 02XETO5pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro
With flavors of sweet spice, coffee, cedar, and a nutty finish, XEN by Nish Patel Toro is a medium bodied cigar. The XEN by Nish Patel cigar is made by Rocky Patel and has a silky smooth Ecuador Connecticut wrapper. It reflects what he loves about cigars.
$31.04
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Maria Mancini Magic Mountain 5 pack

Maria Mancini Magic Mountain
SKU: 02MMMM205pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 54
Strength: Medium
Shape: Pyramid
Maria Mancini's Magic Mountain Figurado is one of the most coveted sizes in the line. The H2000 wrapper covers a Honduran binder, aged Nicaraguan filler, and a Honduran binder. One of the best bargains in the whole, wide cigar world, this bursting Cuban style cigar is packed with rich, earthy flavor.
$28.97
Availability: In Stock

The American by J. C. Newman Robusto 5 pack

The American by J. C. Newman Robusto
SKU: AM45505pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 4.5 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Jeff Borysiewicz and Jon Foster have come together to produce a truly unique cigar - The American. Crafted using the Florida Sun Grown wrapper grown by Borysiewicz in Clermont, along with Foster's Connecticut Broadleaf binder and a filler blend of Foster's Connecticut Havana tobacco and Mennonite-grown tobaccos from Lancaster County, it is set to revive an old 'Cigar City' tradition. Borysiewicz shared his excitement saying, "We are thrilled to see our Florida-grown wrapper being used in a domestically handmade cigar after 50 years of absence."

$85.14
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Asylum PCA Exclusive 2021 Gordo 5 pack

Asylum PCA Exclusive 2021 Gordo
SKU: ASYPCA60605pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 60
Strength: Medium
Shape: Gordo

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

The Asylum PCA Exclusive is available through cigar retailers who attended the annual trade show held by the Premium Cigar Association. There are a variety of large ring-gauge cigars from Asylum cigars that are packed with flavor. This limited-edition, solid medium bodied cigar is made from an all Honduran blend and handcrafted at the Aladino Factory, Honduras.

$84.26
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Drew Estates Legends Copper Label 5 pack

Drew Estates Legends Copper Label
SKU: LEGCOP57545pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 5.75 x 54

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Jonathan Drew is an inspirational force, coming up with some of the most creative cigars out there. His ideas for 'Copper Label' (it's earlier name) was a blend of ACID, Natural and typical blends - and he nailed it. CI Legends by Drew Estate undoubtedly ranks among the top infused cigars made by Drew Estate. Wrapped in a gorgeous Ecuadorian Connecticut leaf, this handmade combines robust Nicaraguan long-fillers with Dominican Piloto tobacco. These condimented tobaccos are carefully mixed with amaretto and hazelnut flavors, culminating in a delightful experience. Starting off sweetly, it blesses your palate with plentiful velvety taste, revealing hints of coffee along with traces of hazelnut and pepper at its center. It's gentle to medium-bodied yet highly savory.

$31.42
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Pichardo Clasico Natural Toro 5 pack

Pichardo Clasico Natural Toro
SKU: PCN65505pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6.5 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

The Pichardo Clasico Natural Toro is a well-balanced smoke with a savory profile. Its savory, reddish Ecuadorian Sun-grown wrapper is expertly placed over a binder and filler made of premium Nicaraguan leaves. It is handmade in Nicaragua at the Tabacalera Pichardo factory and offers a smooth, flavorful medium-bodied smoking experience with notes of earth and spice accompanied by a rich tobacco flavor.

$48.86
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Murcielago Toro 5 pack

Murcielago Toro
SKU: MUR60525pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

There are mouthwatering notes of cocoa and sweet spices in this medium-strength cigar. With its dark Mexican San Andres Maduro wrapper covering a Nicaraguan binder and filler, the Murcielago is a cigar for cigar aficionados who love maduro cigars or who wish to venture into the darker side of cigars.

$52.12
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

All Saints Cigars Dedicacion Huge 5 pack

All Saints Cigars Dedicacion Huge
SKU: ASD60605pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 60
Strength: Medium
Shape: Gordo

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

In 2019, Micky Pegg and two of his companions—Frank Layo and Martin Corboy—established All Saint Cigars. They tapped into Rocky Patel’s Tabacalera Villa Cuba S.A. factory located in Nicaragua to craft the company's cigars. The Dedicación line from All Saints offers an aromatic mixture of cedar and dark chocolate as its primary notes, with subordinate impressions of creamy peanuts, leather, espresso beans, cocoa nibs, hay and cedar along with a light seasoning. This cigar delivers a mild to medium smoke which culminates in the medium realm, resulting in a multi-faceted blend packed with flavors. It has been enthusiastically appraised by many reviewers earning numerous scores over 90 points.

$49.04
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Limited Cigar Association: Incredible Hug East Edition by AJ Fernandez 5 pack

Limited Cigar Association: Incredible Hug East Edition by AJ Fernandez
SKU: IHE60565pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 56
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Privada Cigar Club launched the Limited Cigar Association in 2020, granting connoisseurs an unprecedented opportunity: Partnering with renowned cigar brands and personalities, Privada produces limited-release cigars exclusively available through LCA and its retail partners. With a new release every month, you can always expect something intriguing from the LCA. Its June 2023 release — the Incredible Hug cigar— is an especially novel offering by AJ Fernandez that offers a powerful punch tempered by a gentle caress on the palate. This two-edition cigar is split between EAST and WEST versions based on retailers' location, and here we have access to the EAST edition made of Nicaraguan Habano wrapper in 6" x 56 size.

$57.67
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Makers Mark 538 5 pack

Makers Mark 538
SKU: MAKMRK50385pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 5 x 38
Strength: Mild
Shape: Petite Corona

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

It used to be commonplace for cigar aficionados to douse their sticks with brandy or bourbon before kindling them up, but such practices have since ceased and rightly so; the results could only be described as 'quite a mess.' Maker's Mark now can provide enthusiasts with the combination of fine cigars and bourbon through an innovative infusion process. Refraining from directly exposing the tobacco to the liquid, Maker's Mark instead infuse their cigars with select flavours and scents unique to their recipe. Crafted using Dominican long-filler tobaccos, these cigars deliver a smooth yet distinctive smoke enhanced by the refinement of Maker's Mark bourbon. Lastly, each stogie is encased in a glass tube sealed with the famous red wax bearing Maker's Mark's signature, making sure the fine aromas of both bourbon and tobacco remain perfectly preserved at optimal humidity.

$47.80
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Romeo y Julieta Envy Amulet 5 pack

Romeo y Julieta Envy Amulet
SKU: RJE60555pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Romeo y Julieta have made an incredible name for themselves with years of experience, quality construction, delicious flavors, and fresh releases. The Envy breathes new life into the brand, crafted in collaboration with the renowned Plasencia family and limited-edition 6" x 55 toros. Nicaraguan tobaccos across the board make for a medium to full-bodied experience complemented by a Jalapa wrapper. Smoking this cigar is all about embracing Romeo y Julieta's love for their craft - and you may very well experience a bit of envy when you do!

$82.06
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Romeo y Julieta Book of Love Toro 5 pack

Romeo y Julieta Book of Love Toro
SKU: RJBL60525pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 52
Shape: Toro

No cigar lover can deny Romeo Y Julieta's influence on the global industry. Founded in Cuba, they are one of the most widely known brands in the world. Today, their newest entry into the market is an impressive limited-edition blend: Romeo’s Book of Love. Comprised of a Dominican core and binder, as well as an Ecuadorian wrapper, this richly flavored cigar offers up notes of cedar, dark chocolate and a slight spiciness on the finish. This medium to full-bodied smoke comes in an exquisite 10-count box that looks like an old book. Whether you love or hate them, it's clear this outstanding limited edition is another example of why Romeo Y Julieta remains at the top of its game.

$62.07
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Artista Harvest Midnight Box Press Toro 5 pack

Artista Harvest Midnight Box Press Toro
SKU: ARTM60505pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 50
Strength: Full
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Artista Series is a novel approach to blending tobaccos, bringing you our best work yet after years of hard work, development, and learning from failure and capitalizing on success. As our first premium full-bodied cigar, Artista Midnight features an Ecuadorian Habano wrapper. A Connecticut shade binder adds sweetness and three different kinds of fillers impart an incredible flavor profile.

$50.79
Availability: In Stock

Las Calaveras Edicion Limitada 2023 LC54 5 pack

Las Calaveras Edicion Limitada 2023 LC54
SKU: LCAL55545pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 5.625 x 54
Strength: Full
Shape: Torpedo

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

With a savory complexity complemented by spices, coffee, and sweetness, this cigar is a potent, flavorful cigar. My Father Cigars handmade the cigars in Nicaragua with a Connecticut Broadleaf maduro wrapper that surrounds a Nicaraguan binder and filler. As its name implies, Las Calaveras Edicion Limitada 2023 is produced in limited quantities, so order your boxes today to enjoy this year's rich flavors and fine craftsmanship.

$70.88
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Artista Harvest Sumatra Box Press Robusto 5 pack

Artista Harvest Sumatra Box Press Robusto
SKU: ARTH50545pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 5 x 54
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Artista Series is a novel approach to blending tobaccos, reflecting years of hard work, development, learning from failure and capitalizing on success to bring you our best work yet. An exquisite Sumatra wrapper, a flavorful Habano Seco binder, and a blend of filler that is unlike anything we’ve ever seen before make up Artista Harvest.

$49.92
Availability: In Stock

Casdagli Basilica A Toro 5 pack

Casdagli Basilica A Toro
SKU: BESBA60525pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Full
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

The Casdagli Basilica A Toro is a full-bodied premium cigar with a unique shaggy foot that exposes the filler for an enhanced flavor experience. This flavorful toro boasts a tantalizing natural Dominican Republic Cotui wrapper and aged Dominican Republic Bonao binder. The filler consists of carefully selected tobaccos from Peru, Nicaragua, Dominican Republic, and the USA. The exquisite blend offers a harmonious sweetness with hints of vanilla, chocolate, and oak. Handmade at the Kelner Boutique Factory in the Dominican Republic, this exceptional cigar earned a 96% "Extraordinary" rating from Blind Man's Puff in 2018.

$86.90
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Cohiba Riviera Perfecto Box Pressed 5 pack

Cohiba Riviera Perfecto Box Pressed
SKU: COHR60605pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 60
Strength: Medium
Shape: Perfecto

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Cohiba is a renowned brand known for its extravagant blends and superb construction. You'll find this top-shelf brand in any store, calling out your name. Don't settle for cube steak, when you can indulge in a fillet with Cohiba. This brand is perfect for celebrating special moments and adding a touch of elegance. The latest release from the Cohiba Royale is full of exciting firsts for the brand, coming from General Cigar's factory in Esteli, Nicaragua. A first-ever box-pressed Cohiba with top-notch construction awaits us. The blend features meticulously bunched Honduran and Nicaraguan long-fillers and a Honduran broadleaf binder. But the most notable "first" is the use of a dark and oily Mexican San Andres wrapper. The filler and binder tobaccos were all grown in Jamaicastran Valley and La Entrada, along with tobaccos from Esteli and Condega in Nicaragua. Medium to full-bodied, this blend offers rich flavors of dark chocolate, coffee beans, and leather that are sure to impress.

$115.17
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Weller by Cohiba Toro 5 pack

Weller by Cohiba Toro
SKU: COHW60505pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Known as one of the top contenders in the cigar industry, Cohiba's Cuban legacy brand is recognized by many, even those who do not partake in smoking cigars. It was a no-brainer to pair this prestigious name with another leading brand, bourbon. The latest edition of their partnership, Weller by Cohiba, may just be their most impressive creation yet. This third installment features a binder crafted from Connecticut-grown broadleaf, aged in genuine Weller Bourbon barrels. Beneath it lies a blend of Nicaraguan and Brazilian tobaccos, all encased in a Nicaraguan Jalapa wrapper. Expect flavors of oak, earth, and spice with subtle notes of molasses on the finish. Don't hesitate to secure your limited edition box now before they're gone!

$137.10
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Fratello Arlequin Gordo Prensado 5 pack

Fratello Arlequin Gordo Prensado
SKU: FRATA60585pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 6 x 58
Strength: Medium
Shape: Gordo

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

In June 2019, Fratello Arlequin was introduced alongside the Space Fresh Packs. The aim was for consumers to select their preferred cigar from the two options offered in the pack and share their feedback with the Fratello Team. After careful consideration of all votes, the blend that came out on top was chosen for Fratello Arlequin. This box-pressed cigar is expertly crafted at Joya de Nicaragua in Esteli, using a Mexican San Andres wrapper and an Ecuador Habano binder with filler tobaccos from both Peru and Nicaragua. The end result is a medium to full bodied smoke bursting with rich, complex flavors. It strikes a perfect balance between the earthy notes of the San Andres Maduro wrapper and the spiciness of the binder and filler tobaccos.

$57.40
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

J. London "The Ripper" Robusto 5 pack

J. London "The Ripper" Robusto
SKU: JLR52505pack
Package: Package of 5
Size: 5.25 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

The J. London brand stands in a tier shared by only a select few cigar brands. For those who may be unaware, this is the top-shelf tier where ultra-premium blends reside and are reserved for special occasions. These are not your average yardwork cigars. Instead, they are reserved for moments that call for something exceptional. For The Ripper blend from J. London, a combination of Dominican and Nicaraguan tobaccos is used, wrapped in an Ecuadorian Habano binder and finished off with a smooth Ecuadorian Corojo wrapper. This medium to full-bodied blend offers flavors of cedar, earth, and pepper on the finish. Each box contains one cigar with a unique dagger design carved from tobacco on the wrapper.

$62.24
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock
Showing 1 to 25 of 33

Disclaimer

TheCigarStore.com does not sell tobacco products to anyone under the age of 21. TheCigarStore.com does not sell cigarettes. It is unlawful to purchase cigars below the minimum age. If you are not at least 21 years of age, please do not enter our site.